Arkham?!

Indeed. Sort of. Arkham is where the asylum is. This takes place in Innsmouth, which I believe is north of Arkham.

H. P. Lovecraft, rather than Batman, I think.

Minor note:
‘Martha, ever daddy’s little girl’
should, be:
‘Martha, every daddy’s little girl’

@Funky Chunky: “ever daddy’s little girl” makes sense (i.e., “always daddy’s little girl”).

Again, nice mystery. Out of curiosity, how do you enter a story as both a sequel and a challenge entry? Thought that used to be impossible.

Thanks, Stovohobo, good point. My mistake :)